Skip to main content
ClientFirst Wealth, Legacy & Estate Planning
Reading glasses resting on an open book on a wooden table

The Retirement Transition Trap™

Why the First Five Years of Retirement Matter More Than the Next Twenty

Edward P. Mahaffy, CFP®, ChFC®November 17, 20269 min read

The early years of retirement can carry extra weight. See how early market losses, spending, and a tested budget affect how long your savings last.

Key Takeaways:

  • Retirement starts when your savings are largest and your paycheck is gone. Your first withdrawals (the money you take out of savings to live on) set a pattern the later years build on. The later years still matter too.
  • A market drop early in retirement can hurt more than the same drop later. Selling investments to pay bills after a drop leaves less money invested for any recovery. Your results depend on your own situation.
  • Room to adjust gives you more ways to respond. A tested budget and a coordinated plan can help you handle rising prices, health costs, and surprises.

You've spent decades building your savings, and now they have to pay your bills. The Social Security Administration's life tables show that a 65-year-old man can expect about 18 more years on average, and a 65-year-old woman about 21, so your savings may need to last a long time.¹ The early part of that stretch can be hard to predict. In a 2026 survey, about 2 in 5 retirees said their spending in retirement has been higher than they expected.²

You'll hear that the first five years of retirement matter more than the next twenty. Taken literally, that's an overstatement, since every year counts. The fairer version is that the early years can carry extra weight, because the choices you make then set habits the later years build on, while you still have the most room to change course. If you're preparing for the retirement transition or already living it, these are the pieces worth understanding.

Why Do the First Five Years of Retirement Carry So Much Weight?

Retirement starts at the point when your savings are probably at their largest and your paycheck has stopped. You begin taking money out to cover your bills, and your first choices about how much to spend and where to take it from set the pattern for years. That makes the early years especially important.

It doesn't mean the later years are unimportant. It means the early years are when you have the most at stake and usually the most room to adjust. A change in year two is typically easier to make than one in year twenty.

ClientFirst Wealth, Legacy & Estate Planning calls the years around retirement The Retirement Transition Trap™. It describes a stretch when a rough run in the markets, combined with the withdrawals now paying for your life, can do damage that's hard to undo.

How Can Early Market Losses Affect Your Withdrawals?

When you sell investments to pay your bills after prices drop, you have to sell more shares to get the same dollars, and those shares can't grow back if prices recover. Financial professionals call this sequence of returns risk, which is the risk that bad investment returns arrive early, right after you start taking withdrawals.

While you were working, a market drop could even help you, because each paycheck kept buying investments at lower prices. In retirement the paycheck is gone, so the same drop can force you to sell. Two retirees can earn the same average return over 20 years and still end up in different places, depending on when the bad years land.

An example shows how this works. Say you retire with a portfolio (your collection of investments) worth $1,000,000 and spend $50,000 a year from it, which is 5 percent of the balance. If the portfolio drops 20 percent in the first year, it's worth $800,000, and that same $50,000 is now 6.25 percent of what's left. The dollars you sold during the drop are gone, so they can't join the recovery.

Please note: This example is for illustration only. It ignores investment growth, taxes, and inflation, and it doesn't predict results or point to a rate that's right for you. How your investments are arranged for this stage is a separate topic, covered in how your investments should change as retirement approaches.

Does Your Retirement Budget Hold Up in Year One?

Your budget holds up only if you've tested it against what you expect to spend and the income you can count on. A budget that looks fine on paper can fall apart once the first year of actual bills arrives.

Testing it starts with three numbers:

  • What you'll spend: housing, food, taxes, travel, gifts, and the occasional large bill.
  • Income you can count on: Social Security (monthly payments from the government based on your work history), a pension, and other steady income.
  • What your investments must cover: the gap between the first two numbers.

After decades of working, it's natural to want the trips, the new car, maybe helping the grandchildren. That's part of what the money is for. Those costs need to fit inside the larger income plan, because a spending surge during a market drop can create a problem that doesn't fix itself when prices recover. The wider list of changes is covered in what changes financially when you retire.

What Can Inflation, Healthcare, and Surprise Expenses Change?

All three can push your spending above your starting budget, and they run on their own schedules rather than yours.

Inflation Raises the Price of Everything

Inflation means prices rise over time, so the same groceries cost more each year. Social Security payments adjust for it through a yearly cost-of-living adjustment, a raise based on the Consumer Price Index, which is a government measure of price changes. The most recent one, announced in October 2026, is 3.6 percent for 2027.³ Your withdrawals from savings may need to rise over time too, depending on your situation.

Healthcare Costs Can Take a Bigger Share

Medicare is the government health insurance most people join at 65, and it still comes with premiums (monthly payments) and out-of-pocket costs. Health costs often take up a larger share of a budget as people get older. If you retire before 65, you may need to cover your own insurance until Medicare starts.

Surprises and Lifestyle Changes

A roof repair, a family member who needs help, a move, or a change in health can push spending up or down. These are hard to predict, which is why a plan needs some room for them.

How Flexibility and a Coordinated Plan Keep Your Options Open

Flexibility means having more than one way to respond when something changes, and a coordinated plan shows you those options before you need them. A plan that fits together your Social Security, investment accounts, and other income can help you see how much room you have.

Your options might include spending a little less for a while, choosing which account to take money from, or keeping some cash on hand so you're not selling investments during a drop. Which ones make sense depends on your taxes, your health, and your goals.

These are the pieces worth getting right early on:

  • Your income floor: the monthly bills covered by steady income, like Social Security or a pension, before your investments have to step in.
  • A tested budget: spending you've checked against actual costs.
  • A withdrawal approach built for you: a plan for how much to take out and from which accounts, shaped by your taxes and age rather than a generic percentage.
  • A regular check-in: a scheduled look at how your spending, investments, and health costs are playing out.

Putting these together is the heart of retirement income planning, which means building a plan for how your savings turn into a paycheck.

What Should You Think About in Each Stage of Retirement?

Your priorities shift as the years go on. The early years are about getting your plan running and testing it against actual life, and the later years are about keeping it on track as things change. This timeline is a general guide, so your own dates will depend on your age, health, and goals.

The First Five Years

In the early years, the work is watching how your plan plays out and adjusting before habits settle in:

  • Year One: Start your withdrawals and compare your actual spending with your budget each month. Watch for one-time costs, like a move or a big trip, so you can tell them apart from your everyday spending.
  • Years Two and Three: Look at how your spending, taxes, and health costs compare with what you planned. Check that you're drawing from the accounts you intended and that you're holding enough cash so a market drop doesn't force you to sell investments.
  • Years Four and Five: By now you have several years of actual numbers. Decide whether your spending level still fits your income, and make changes early, while they're easier to make.

The Next Twenty Years

After the first five years, the question shifts from setting up to staying on course:

  • Years Six to Ten: Keep your regular reviews going. Prices keep rising, and your spending may shift as your activities change, so update your budget and your withdrawals to match.
  • Years Eleven to Fifteen: Health costs often take a larger share of a budget as people age, so check that your plan leaves room for them. Tax rules can change over time, so review how they apply to your accounts.
  • Years Sixteen to Twenty-Five: Some people live well past the averages, so keep your plan flexible enough to last. This is also a good time to confirm that your beneficiaries (the people you've named to receive your accounts) and estate documents, like a will, still match your wishes, and to decide who could help manage your finances if you needed it.

Early Retirement Years FAQs

1. Can I Still Retire if the Market Is Down?

It can be possible, depending on your income sources, your spending, and how much room you have to adjust. A plan tested against a weak start can show you whether your timing works or needs to change. No one can predict where markets will go, so the goal is to see how your plan holds up under different conditions.

2. Do the Early Years Still Matter if the Market Does Well?

Yes. A strong market can give you more room, but your spending habits, rising prices, and health costs still shape how long your savings last. A good start is a cushion, and it's still worth testing your plan against a tougher stretch.

3. Should I Spend More in the First Years Because I'm Healthier and More Active?

Some people do spend more early in retirement, because they have the energy to travel and enjoy it. That's a fair goal as long as you build it into the plan on purpose. Planned spending can be tested against your income, while spending that sneaks up on you hasn't been tested at all.

Put a Retirement Income Plan Behind Your First Five Years

ClientFirst Wealth, Legacy & Estate Planning helps people coordinate their retirement income, taxes, and investments so they fit together. We look at the years around retirement as one connected stretch, which is the thinking behind The Retirement Transition Trap™, and we build plans that account for market ups and downs, your spending, and your long-term goals. No plan can remove market risk or predict how long savings will last.

If you're close to retirement or already in its first few years, we'd welcome the chance to talk. Schedule a complimentary consultation to build or review a retirement income plan that fits your situation.

Resources:

  1. Actuarial Life Table
  2. Retirement Confidence Survey Findings
  3. Cost-of-Living Adjustment

This presentation is not an offer or a solicitation to buy or sell securities. The information contained in this presentation has been compiled from third-party sources and is believed to be reliable; however, its accuracy is not guaranteed and should not be relied upon in any way whatsoever. This presentation may not be construed as investment, tax or legal advice and does not give investment recommendations. Any opinion included in this report constitutes our judgment as of the date of this report and is subject to change without notice.

Additional information, including management fees and expenses, is provided on our Form ADV Part 2 available upon request or at the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure website, www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

The views expressed are those of the author as of the date noted, are subject to change based on market and other various conditions. Material discussed is meant to provide general information and it is not to be construed as specific investment, tax or legal advice. Keep in mind that current and historical facts may not be indicative of future results. The information contained in our presentations has been compiled from third party sources and is believed to be reliable; however, accuracy is not guaranteed.

Questions about your own situation?

Step one is a 15-minute discovery phone call about your situation: your concerns, your goals, and whether our firm is a good fit. No cost, no obligation, and no requirement to transfer assets.